• Welcome to Autism Forums, a friendly forum to discuss Aspergers Syndrome, Autism, High Functioning Autism and related conditions.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Private Member only forums for more serious discussions that you may wish to not have guests or search engines access to.
    • Your very own blog. Write about anything you like on your own individual blog.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon! Please also check us out @ https://www.twitter.com/aspiescentral

Would Prayer in Schools Have Stopped the Massacre?

Once more Aspergers is in the news and not in a positive way. I am afraid that it may backfire on all of us, especially young males. I wish I knew what the answer was.

I wonder, was this troubled young man a member of one of our forums, either AC or another? Is there something any of us could have said that would have stopped him? Are there others right now who might be thinking similar thoughts? If so, what can we do? Because I believe we are better equipped to reach out to each other than the NT world.

We were talking about this at Bible group last night. It has got several members way upset. I am not sure I understand why. Maybe it's the Aspy part of me that says, look, the odds of that happening again are probably very remote. On the other hand, they have realized that our schools are not very secure. That anyone anytime can walk right in. That it seems to be business as usual, as if this had never happened.

A couple of people said last night that the reason this happened is because God has been taken out of the schools. That unless we require students to recite a prayer (whose prayer?) or observe a moment of silence we are going to see more incidents of this kind. It was all I could do to keep my mouth shut.

You want to talk about prayer in school? Well, I went to a school that prayed and I went to a school that did not pray and as far as I am concerned there was no difference between them in the way that I was treated. Reciting holy words did not make those students kinder, more concerned for others. It was just another hoop to be jumped through. Hey, I got news for you, just because this hasn't happened yet at a Christian school, does not mean that it won't. And then what?

I know someone, a retired police officer, who does not attend church and does not have any use for organized religion (he says it's just a bunch of hypocrites) yet he too thinks that society went to hell in a handbasket when public school prayer was outlawed. I asked him, why do you think this is a good thing to make little kids do when you yourself do not pray or go to church. He said, "social control." It's a way of unifying people and making them conform. Has nothing whatsoever with faith or belief or even whether there is a God. Hitler understood that very well. He too agreed that a people needed something to unite them, something bigger than themselves.

From my experience in the praying school I can tell you that there were plenty of kids who outwardly conformed, they said the words, but behind the teacher's back, they snickered. Yet the pro-school prayer crowd seems to be oblivious to that fact. They don't realize that they are actually working to cheapen something they hold very precious. And that in focusing on restoring prayer in schools they are taking the easy way out. That once they achieve their goal their responsibility is over. It's a simplistic answer to a very complex problem and it will not work.

Frankly I don't think we are ever going to know the whole story behind what motivated this man to do what he did. And while I certainly do not condone mowing down elementary students, the truth is, as we've said so many times, is that "children are cruel." No one wants to face the fact that maybe some of these kids might not have been so innocent. Kids DO tease. They DO mock. Did some of those students go by his house every day and call names? It happens. We here on the forum know that. We don't have our heads in the sands. Could it be that this might have been the trigger? If so, I can guarantee that we will never hear about it.

When the church wanted to hold Bible camp in my yard and a couple of the women went around passing out flyers, they were told by the kids, "Oh, yes, we know where that is, that is Cat Lady's yard." Now, Cat Lady is pretty mild considering some of the names I have been called, but the point is, as far as those kids AND THEIR PARENTS were concerned, I DID NOT HAVE A NAME. And I bet that neither one of the women bothered to correct them and say, "She has a name. It is ____." People, we can't go on like that if we are really serious about ending school violence.

And if we are going to talk about prayer, then ultimately the responsibility for what happened belongs to God. He allowed it to happen. He allowed this man to be born with Aspergers and possibly other mental issues. He allowed him to steal the guns and go to the school and pull the trigger while He, the Lord of the universe, the caring one, sat on His throne and turned His head. Please do not give me any BS about free will here. If God exists, he could have stopped it. He chose not to. And that makes him as much a monster as the man who pulled the trigger.

Comments

Another great & thought provoking blog, Compass. I so enjoy your writing. I too wondered about whether or not this guy was someone we know. A few months ago there was a young man here & he expressed many disturbing, violent, nihilistic, suicidal ideas that we all tried earnestly to dissuade him from. Although he claimed to be older & was clearly intelligent, he wrote with the maturity of a late teen/20-something. At one point, I wrote to the mods expressing concern that this young man was going to do something horrible & if it was possible to give his contact info to the authorities. But, at that point, all he was guilty of was disturbing thoughts: hardly a crime!

As for prayers in the schools, America is one of the most church-going nations with a significant & growing number of wild eyed Christian fanatics who have a disturbingly ignorant & superstitious medieval outlook. We look on in trepidation & see many parallels between these fanatics & the Islamists in the middle east. Between the bible camp documentaries & the purity ball nuts, cult-like religious fanaticism has become mainstream. So long as the adherents are white & call what they're doing Christianity, they will be able to hide behind a halo. I'm so glad my kids are not in those schools. I don't want my kids taught a bunch of superstitious gibberish about how some magical invisible dead martyr is going to solve their problems, manage their lives & 'act in mysterious ways'.

The entire human 'perfect sacrifice'story of Jesus makes me shudder. There's nothing good about some divine psychopath who created so-called sinful humans, then is so spiteful & egocentric that he can only 'forgive' them (for what, exactly?) unless he first allows them to torture & murder his son...Soooo...that makes everything okay?

The overwhelming majority of US school shooters emerged from Christian backgrounds. I can see where the distorted god/Jesus/martyrdom/human sacrifice/revenge myths they were raised to believe in to at least some degree, have informed their behaviour. Middle class entitlement also plays a role: kids in the ghetto have yet to see one of their kids go AWOL & shoot up the school. There are violent acts between individuals fighting over this or that or some perceived slight, but nothing like what these privileged mostly white middle class boys are doing. I can see where a kid like Lanza could convince himself that he is a divine force making these kids pay for their sins but ultimately sending them to 'a better place'. Didn't the president say, "God has called them home" ? Sheesh: next time just send a text message!

As with hurricane Katrina, Christian voices (not all, but an alarming number of them) began immediately intoning insanities about how this is god's will & gods punishment for how sinful America has become, for having bowed to 'the gay agenda', for having removed prayer from school & for a host of other nonsense. Can they say that with a straight face? Their so-called loving caring all good god sends Lanza (& the like) as divine emissaries, prophets of judgement to murder hapless innocent 6 yr olds in order to 'teach sinners a lesson'?!? If so, then Lanza didn't do wrong & neither did Klebold & Harris. If this is god's will, then he is indeed sicker, more devious & twisted than any in his creation. If this is divine logic, holy thinking & an act of divine will, then what work is left for their devil: allowing a loving gay couple to marry? Are we to see Lanza as a modern day Judas Iscariot, the 'declencheur' of divine justice? How can we expect people to be anything other than psychopaths & narcissists when their god, their ideal is a master of both?
 

Blog entry information

Author
Spinning Compass
Read time
4 min read
Views
668
Comments
2
Last update

More entries in General

  • Messages
    I gave it my all during today's 1:1 PT session at the gym. It was tough, but he was happy that I...
  • A trip to the woods
    A trip into the local Fens and Nine Acre Woods. Ed
  • Today's first solo gym session
    Gym session went well. Given how sore my muscles were, I'm surprised that I could do 3 sets of...
  • First solo trip
    This muscle soreness is going to make today's first solo gym session a case of mind over matter...
  • Tonight I trance
    I give an offering of some of my water each time I visit the old oak tree. Respect your elders...

More entries from Spinning Compass

Share this entry

Top Bottom