There are people who experience mental health issues after taking shamanic plants recreationally. But that's not the fault of the plant they are taking, it is unfortunately the result of taking something they are not trained and prepared for. For those who use a shamanic plant recreationally to get high, doesn't make the plant at fault if it affects them negatively.
I have never taken ayahuasca, peyote, I have had LSA and mushrooms.
It is only lately that I think exactly the same as what you have written here.
People who are troubled, who book retreats and expect all of their problems to go away are more at risk of mental illness, when day-to-day life kicks back in, and they cannot handle the piffle of it all.
Those who stand the best chance of having a shamanic experience of these plants are the ones who are used to being in a meditative state, preferably starting in childhood. The geeky kid who could be found in the library reading fiction, not caring if he was bullied.
The arty kid who was alone but not lonely, who didn't care that he wasn't in the in-crowd.
The musical kid who showed bullies that losing a fight wouldn't make him scared of them.
Any traumatised kid who engaged in creative activities that enabled them to move through their trauma in a healthy way, to move them on and dissolve the charge of the negative energy from the trauma.
The difference between the "cool" kids/bullied wannabe kids, and the "un-cool" bookworm, arty, musical kids is that the second group cultivated inner silence from an age when their brain was developing, so they became stronger from that abuse they may have received, they became calmer, slower-talking, and more self-reliant and self directed.
I know some people have difficult experiences with these plants, others have seen their kids become mentally unstable, and become advocates of having it banned. This is not the fault of the plant, this is a problem with society today, and it is why governments have until recently controlled all these substances rather than make them freely available.
I've watched retreats online and many say they feel cleansed initially. The kids who become mentally unstable fall into the category of the group of kids who did not engage in creative activities as a child to process abuse/trauma.
The plants revealed it to them, maybe in retreat, they were able to talk to fellow people there and facilitators/shamen, but back in day-to-day life, the old energies emerge.
These sorts of people are still blocked.
The problem with prohibition is that all it does is encourage things to go underground and give rise to the criminal activities of supplying it. If it's going to be around anyway, it makes more sense that it is controlled and regulated to ensure a standard of quality, and in a compassionate society, should there be issues as a result of using it, we are ready to step in to help. But calling for these plants to be banned is wrong.
I agree with what you say about prohibition and will go a step further to venture "Is it done to create more pain, death and misery?" I ask because of the hideous drug "Spice" look at what that is doing to people.
I have a knife. It's a really useful tool to cut things with, but if I decide to stab somebody, it doesn't mean all knives should be prohibited. The problem would lie with me not with the knife.
I loved the knife analogy.
Back in the day, thousands of years ago, only the shamans used substances like this. At the time of the first temple in Judea, where the priests went into the inner sanctum, the holy of holies. Nobody really knew what they did in there. I suspect what they were doing was using entheogenic plants to divine and connect with God. Nobody would know they were doing that because it wouldn't be relevant to them.
To add to this, there are lots of ancient monuments that depict psychedelics. Also, look at, for instance, the intricate patterns on mosques etc, I wonder if they used entheogen in the ancient Middle East before modern dogmatic Islam took ahold.
The role of the Shaman is to impart wisdom and take care of the spiritual needs of the village. The plants are used to assist this process, and only those who are able to use them or have been trained and initiated in their proper use should.
I agree. May I ask, have you had ayahuasca? I haven't. I fall into the category of kids who did not prepare meditatively in childhood.
Unfortunately today, plants like cannabis, and other shamanic plants, can be obtained by anyone who has a mind to do so, and while I would not stop people from using what they think is right for them, it's very important that we understand that if there are negative consequences from doing so, it is the result of their choice and their practice not the substance itself.
Yes, I fully agree.