Well, I am going to stir up the pot by saying that there are definitely guys who are out of my league. And it has very little to do with looks.
If you want to be in my league, then you must have comparable education to me. A college degree or some college. High school only may be acceptable if--and only if--you have not ceased your intellectual development since graduation. I want someone I can converse with on my level, not someone I have to talk down to or explain things to. Which leads to:
Being well-read. Being able to converse and understand a wide variety of subjects. Yes, I am asking a lot here and I realize it. But while I may live in a low-income, low-education neighborhood, I travel in many circles that do require a bit of education and intelligence to fit in, and I require that any potential partner be also able to fit in. That means that he needs to know what is appropriate and what is not appropriate behavior in these situations. Trailer park behavior belongs in the trailer park. If that is the only level you can operate on, then you are over your head when it comes to approaching me.
The ability to earn a living by legal means. Being economically self-sufficient. This is a big one for me, because I have been approached by guys who could not afford to take me to McDonalds. I don't care to tie my future to known poverty. I don't care how good-looking your picture is, or what your build is, I am not interested in someone who is looking for a sugar momma. So good financial habits are a must.
Now here is where appearance does make a difference. I want someone who is intimately acquainted with soap and water and a comb. I am not interested in someone who has tattoos scrawled all over their body--and especially if they are prison or gang tattoos. Yes, I know what they look like.
I am also very interested in how you treat others and especially how you deal with conflict, disappointment, change of plans. How you see yourself fitting in the scheme of things. Do you believe men and women are fundamentally equal, or do you believe that men are more equal than women? How do you see decision making in a relationship. What is your parents' marriage like? And yes, what baggage do you have from your childhood and/or past relationships?
I have been out with guys who became angry with me because I did not fit whatever picture they had in their minds. They were not truly attracted to me because of the kind of person I was. I have been told by my female friends that I have a sparkle to my personality, that I have this or that desirable character trait, that I am a good person, a caring person, etc. This is not what the men who seek to go out with me are interested in. The things that my friends consider admirable are actually liabilities. I've been told more than once by men that I scare men away. Somehow they feel intimidated.
All I can say about relationships is that they are complex and require a lot of thought and I have not been able to succeed in them. Because our values and ideas were too mismatched.