Cake and Ice Cream

[Xinyta]

This is something I have been thinking about alot with my birthday coming up.

Is it me or does cake and ice cream seem kinda weird together? I mean texturally. I have a bit of a issue with the flakiness of cake and the smoothness of ice cream mixing together. For me the cake bits ruin the pleasing smoothness of ice cream. If I do have it on the same plate, I like to eat them separately.

Am I alone on this?

 

[Sypher37]

Not for me. That sounds like heaven!

I’m sure you’re not alone, however.

 

[Patrick Bushdiecker]

This is something I have been thinking about alot with my birthday coming up.

Is it me or does cake and ice cream seem kinda weird together? I mean texturally. I have a bit of a issue with the flakiness of cake and the smoothness of ice cream mixing together. For me the cake bits ruin the pleasing smoothness of ice cream. If I do have it on the same plate, I like to eat them separately.

Am I alone on this?

You can get an ice cream cake.

 

[Luca]

You’re not alone. I don’t like them together either, or ice cream cake, for that matter.

I can tolerate ice cream by itself, but any type of cake with frosting makes me nauseous and gives me indigestion.

I would much rather have an almond loaf or a lemon loaf than a cake.

 

[Patrick Bushdiecker]

This is something I have been thinking about alot with my birthday coming up.

Is it me or does cake and ice cream seem kinda weird together? I mean texturally. I have a bit of a issue with the flakiness of cake and the smoothness of ice cream mixing together. For me the cake bits ruin the pleasing smoothness of ice cream. If I do have it on the same plate, I like to eat them separately.

Am I alone on this?

Here's an idea:

 

[Patrick Bushdiecker]

You’re not alone. I don’t like them together either, or ice cream cake, for that matter.

I can tolerate ice cream by itself, but any type of cake with frosting makes me nauseous and gives me indigestion.

I would much rather have an almond loaf or a lemon loaf than a cake.

I'm eating a Snickers ice cream bar right now as I read this because you guys made me want ice cream and luckily I have some

 

[Judge]

This is something I have been thinking about alot with my birthday coming up.

Is it me or does cake and ice cream seem kinda weird together? I mean texturally. I have a bit of a issue with the flakiness of cake and the smoothness of ice cream mixing together. For me the cake bits ruin the pleasing smoothness of ice cream. If I do have it on the same plate, I like to eat them separately.

Am I alone on this?

I've always adored a Baskin & Robbins ice cream cake. Sure the textures are a bit weird, but the taste-OMG!

Now I need to go out for a smoke. Oh yeah, I don't smoke! LOL.....

https://www.baskinrobbins.com/en/ice-cream-cakes

 

[Rodafina]

I am with you! Cake and ice cream are entirely separate desserts. For me, it is not only a textural mismatch, but also, a temperature mismatch. Room temperature cake and cold ice cream. Yuck.

 

[Kisa the tea]

Agree. Just because two foods are good and both desert does not mean they should mix.

 

[Metalhead]

If you eat too much cake, it is the sin of gluttony. But it is ok to eat too much pie, because the sin of pie is always zero.

 

[mysterionz]

No it’s not weird at all.

They make ice-cream cake, but they don't make cake ice cream! Checkmate.

 

[Patrick Bushdiecker]

If you eat too much cake, it is the sin of gluttony. But it is ok to eat too much pie, because the sin of pie is always zero.

If it's gluten free is it still gluttony?

 

[Yeshuasdaughter]

I love cake and ice cream. Especially in the form of ice cream cake.

But here are some other options:

How about a nice, warm, gooey blackberry cobbler, with vanilla ice cream melting on top?

Or cheesecake? It's like cake and ice cream in one.

Or a Hershey's sundae pie? Those are the bomb.

There's lots of other choices.

This is one of my favorites. Fruit tarts!

 

[Patrick Bushdiecker]

That fresh fruit looks awesome but I don't know about making a pie out of it. I would definitely try it once at least.

 

[Yeshuasdaughter]

Here's an idea:View attachment 102357

Wow! It should be illegal to create something that decadent.

 

[Patrick Bushdiecker]

This is something I have been thinking about alot with my birthday coming up.

Is it me or does cake and ice cream seem kinda weird together? I mean texturally. I have a bit of a issue with the flakiness of cake and the smoothness of ice cream mixing together. For me the cake bits ruin the pleasing smoothness of ice cream. If I do have it on the same plate, I like to eat them separately.

Am I alone on this?

Do you like tiramisu?

 

[Patrick Bushdiecker]

I am with you! Cake and ice cream are entirely separate desserts. For me, it is not only a textural mismatch, but also, a temperature mismatch. Room temperature cake and cold ice cream. Yuck.

What about ice cream sandwiches though?

 

[Yeshuasdaughter]

That fresh fruit looks awesome but I don't know about making a pie out of it. I would definitely try it once at least.

It's not so much a pie. Imagine sugared ladyfingers as the crust, topped with vanilla mousse. And then glazed berries on top of that.

 

[Patrick Bushdiecker]

This is something I have been thinking about alot with my birthday coming up.

Is it me or does cake and ice cream seem kinda weird together? I mean texturally. I have a bit of a issue with the flakiness of cake and the smoothness of ice cream mixing together. For me the cake bits ruin the pleasing smoothness of ice cream. If I do have it on the same plate, I like to eat them separately.

Am I alone on this?

What about ice cream sandwiches? Is that not the perfect cake to ice cream ratio

 

[Princess Viola]

I like cake, I like ice cream, but I don't like ice cream on cake.

Now ice cream on pie, that's different.