Not all dogs/owners have this type of training, and some dogs have past trauma that makes them aggressive toward another dog.Why the leash? To take an interesting walk in Winnipeg, I'd stop at my front gate and look at my dog. He'd spin a couple of times and lead off, ranging around for sqirrels to chase, but never outpacing me. After a while, I'd just stop, and in a few seconds he'd reverse direction and take us home another way that I would never have found. If I was leading, he'd stay in the same block in a residential area, and within 3 meters downtown. If I went into a food store, he'd wait, and if I went into an office building or department store, he'd heel so well that I was never challenged for a leash. I didn't have to say a word.
While your dog sounds to be well trained and the area in which you took them seems appropriate, where I live untrained off leash dogs with owners who command public space meant for various purposes is a huge problem.
I don’t mean to inject negativity into the thread, but it pertains very much to hiking in my experience with being able to hike around here. My hiking has become extremely limited because I am tired of breaking up dog fights between my dog, who is on a leash and I am trying to help rehabilitate, and other peoples’ dogs who they deem friendly and let them run amok.
Shevek, I will reiterate it does not sound like you were doing this. But, I have come to absolutely appreciate the leash and appreciate people who use them. If you do not have 100% recall command over your dog, they should not be off leash in a public space.