I'm actually the exact opposite. I'm always perfectly polite and pleasant to be around in real life (some would say dull) but in the virtual world I pretty much always choose the evil/rude/bad playthrough. The reason for this is threefold:
1. I know I'm not really hurting anyone, so I can sate my curiosity about what it feels like and push myself.
2. I am a complete hipster and have always sought out the obscure stuff. Most people choose the good option like the people in this thread, which means that by choosing the evil one I am getting a more unique and tailored experience.
3. I think it makes for a more interesting story. I don't pick every single "evil" option available, but I think it makes for a more rounded character if you have flaws and aren't just goody-two-shoes. I also think you can learn more about other characters be seeing how they respond to adversity (i.e. you) than by being pawns in a generic hero story. I also really like books where the major character is a donkey or has major character flaws leading to conflict instead of being a courteous everyperson who does people's bidding without question. I would not make for a good protagonist...
1. I know I'm not really hurting anyone, so I can sate my curiosity about what it feels like and push myself.
2. I am a complete hipster and have always sought out the obscure stuff. Most people choose the good option like the people in this thread, which means that by choosing the evil one I am getting a more unique and tailored experience.
3. I think it makes for a more interesting story. I don't pick every single "evil" option available, but I think it makes for a more rounded character if you have flaws and aren't just goody-two-shoes. I also think you can learn more about other characters be seeing how they respond to adversity (i.e. you) than by being pawns in a generic hero story. I also really like books where the major character is a donkey or has major character flaws leading to conflict instead of being a courteous everyperson who does people's bidding without question. I would not make for a good protagonist...