I used to have so much trouble with it I would wear sunglasses day and night, choose friends who also had problems meeting my eyes, fight with my psychiatrist about it and come home crying after a store clerk or bus driver eye contact disaster. Until I learned there is no such thing.
Everyone has trouble with eye contact. It's at the top of the list of every psych eval, no matter what you go in for. It's a dance, it's tricky, and it's a game, you're yanked into the thing and it's assumed you want to play. I did not want to play. I didn't want to look into the eyes of others and I was proud of my stance, I didn't think people were very pretty inside and didn't want to open myself up to them. I'm over that, and am just saying, I've spent a ridiculous amount of energy on eye contact, and have come to see it as another time thief where the neurodiverse are held to a higher standard than others.
Eye contact is loaded for everyone. We feel our way through it and try to find the sweet spot and let go before morphing into an uncomfortable stare. People put each other ill at ease with their eye contact every day. And then they let it go, forgiveness is the rule.
Only the sensitive assume there is something wrong with them.
Bullies regularly use eye contact as ugly gestures of dominance in ways worrywarts never would. But if you're posting on a message board about being too harsh with your eye contact, you are not a bully.
If you have awkward characteristics, don't shame them, trust that there are many who will find people who avoid eye contact sweetly charming and mysterious. So long as you glance up quickly now and then to acknowledge the person, and look away again, this is a lovely gesture.
I don't even like standing face to face with people. If at all possible I like to sort of be to the side of them. I have been told I look at people out of the corner of my eye. I never noticed I did that until quite a few people told me that over the years.
I don't like F2F either, it feels too confrontational. And looking at people out of the corner of my eye makes me seem shifty and untrustworthy. But taking proud ownership of our eccentricities, to cultivate a personal sense of style, to me, that's what our social awkwardness is about.
There are trailblazers... All the 1950s beat poets avoided eye contact, and stared intently at the floor when they talked to people (you can see it on youtube) and it looks very chic and otherworldly, which is what they were aiming for. Yes, I do *go there* sometimes for reassurance before taking the bus.