I meant, when you gave your opinion on why what you had said may be useful, that you were probably basing your opinion on something you had learnt, which came from someone with relevant expertise and experience. I thought this all the more, because you used the term assessment, and spoke of the 'person being assessed' whereas here on the forums we are not asking others to assess us, we are peers asking for others takes and ideas. You have said you are doing a therapy training, and the language used sounded like it came from that. If not, what makes you feel you need to assess your peers here?
And also, if that is what you are finding yourself doing, I would suggest looking at yourself, and wondering about how come you feel the need to assess others? One of my friends used to talk about how he could go into what he called Inflatable Jesus mode, when he was first counselling others, maybe something like that could be happening?
Also, there was a great film a good while back, I think it starred Mel Brooks, he was a guy who paid his therapist to tell him the hard truths, but the therapist got so into it he escalated into shouting critiques insults and even sky writing messages. So funny.
But take care, firstly for people's safety, secondly for their feelings, thirdly for the therapeutic bond or relationship; if someone was doing that, this kind of thing would likely and rightly, get you sued in real life therapeutic practice.