• Welcome to Autism Forums, a friendly forum to discuss Aspergers Syndrome, Autism, High Functioning Autism and related conditions.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Private Member only forums for more serious discussions that you may wish to not have guests or search engines access to.
    • Your very own blog. Write about anything you like on your own individual blog.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon! Please also check us out @ https://www.twitter.com/aspiescentral

What are the pro's/con's of a diagnosis?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Chris
  • Start date Start date
C

Chris

Guest
What are the pros/cons of having an official diagnosis? Just thought I'd ask as there are obviously others here who know a lot more about this than me. The only con that comes to mind is you're excluded from certain lines of work in the military.

If you had a professional/private assessment and they confirmed you had AS, although it wasn't official since it isn't through the NHS, would recommend pushing with the NHS to get an official diagnosis or to just leave it?
 
It didn't do one good thing for me except me finding WP and meeting all my friends and my bf and having a little boy (looks NT so far) with him. And that stuff would have happened anyway with a diagnosis of PDD-NOS. I was later re-diagnosed as PDD-NOS, which is what I actually had all along, and good has come out of that.
 
The cons are being denied health insurance, being denied in the military, unable to find a job in the UK.


The pros are you get the help you need in school, you get extra help in life like getting SSI, free health insurance by the state.

In the USA, your diagnoses is kept private and no work will see it when they wish to run a background check on you. Only the gov. will see it if you wish to join the military or something.
 
In theory, a diagnosis is supposed to mean you get the appropriate help & support. I'm still working on that, 2 & 1/2 years after mine. Depends where you live, if there's a good AS support group &/or other help available. Else, AS becomes another source for "you just have to accept...'. Strangely, anybody who says that one minute is saying you can learn, change &/or adapt a little later.
 
The cons are being denied health insurance, being denied in the military, unable to find a job in the UK.


The pros are you get the help you need in school, you get extra help in life like getting SSI, free health insurance by the state.

In the USA, your diagnoses is kept private and no work will see it when they wish to run a background check on you. Only the gov. will see it if you wish to join the military or something.

It's the same here in the UK I think...you don't get asked about that kinda thing when you sign up for a job unless it's government. Such as the military or polie.
 
In Canada the military would not know if you had any diagnosis or not, tho they do ask if you have ever seen a shrink.


At least I don't aspire to the military anymore. I just want to be a psych tech. My bf was a psych tech AFTER he was diagnosed with Major Depressive Disorder, and he says they are not allowed to ask you about your medical or mental health history.
 
I wonder if you'd be able to get a clearance with a diagnosis.

I've worked in the US defense industry before and I'd like to at least have the option to go back to it if I want/need to, but you need to be able to get a security clearance for practically any job connected with defense.
 
I wasn't aware that you can't join the Army with an AS diagnoses. Why not?

The pros for me having an official diagnoses are that I have answers to a lot of questions about myself. I now understand why i'm different and can't socialise successfully. I can also get learning support at college.

I can't think of any cons.
 
To pipe in on the military convert, any emotional/mental illness gets you out of the military in the US, cause they will ask. My husband got denied re-entry into the amry after 9/11 because he has a food allergy.

It also can/could get you out of jury duty!

PROS: I now know why i say and act and do the things i do and do not do.

CONS: Possible more medical for therapy and medication.
 
"The importance of having your child evaluated and obtaining a formal diagnosis cannot be stressed enough. A diagnosis of Asperger’s can be very tricky because, for most children, symptoms vary and change over time. Symptoms of various conditions do overlap and patients may have several conditions at the same time.

Regardless of the outcome of an evaluation, having a diagnosis of any illness provides a beginning for parents. If there is an illness or disorder diagnosed, the parent can then obtain a ‘road map’ for coping with or healing the child.

Not only is it important to obtain an early, specific diagnosis from a doctor or therapist, it is also important to obtain a second opinion. Many childhood behaviours mimic one another, and a second opinion is invaluable when assessing a child’s behaviour. Since Asperger’s Syndrome varies greatly from one person to the next, with some having many, serious problems and others having only minor problems, obtaining a second opinion can confirm a diagnosis of Asperger’s Syndrome.

Also, it is important to obtain an early diagnosis because early intervention and treatment often lead to greater success. And also, age-appropriate learning proceeds without any unnecessary delay.

Many children with Asperger’s are very intelligent and clever. They are able to cover up difficulties and may not be diagnosed until they are adults. Many adults with Asperger’s Syndrome are very high-functioning people who learn various coping mechanisms on their own. The most widely recognized diagnostic tool for Asperger’s Syndrome is the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. Known as the DSM, it has the full diagnostic criteria for pervasive developmental disorders such autism and Attention-Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD). A good explanation of the criteria for autism and ADHD can be found at www.childbrain.com website.

As defined in DSM-IV, the most recent revision of the DSM, the criteria for Asperger’s Syndrome (AS) follow the same format as for autism. The symptoms are organized by onset, social and emotional, and “restricted interests” criteria, as well as motor deficits and isolated special skills. A final criterion for Asperger’s is the exclusion of other conditions, such as autism itself and Pervasive Developmental Disorder. The child might exhibit behavioural delays or deviant behavioural patterns in multiple areas of functioning.

If diagnosed, it will be helpful to explore resources for your son, such as an Asperger’s specialist who can teach him social skills and help him understand his diagnosis. Assuming that your child is currently in school, the first place to look for help is at school. School counsellors have been trained in teaching learning skills as well as basic techniques of psychology. They maintain a working knowledge of DSM diagnostic criteria, and many of them work closely with doctors and psychiatrists when they are formulating a child’s diagnosis.

Many countries mandate evaluations of all students who may have a disability – of any kind. The evaluation leads to a plan for remediation and assistance. If your child is out of school, find a licensed psychologist (one who has a Ph.D. from an accredited university) to help him and refer him to the resources that are available for people with Asperger’s Syndrome."

http://parentingaspergers.com/blog/getting-an-aspergers-diagnosis-the-pros-and-cons
 
this one made me lol

"Pros: People don't always care that you have no idea how to get along with other people
Con: You can remain a virgin for the same reason - behavior disorders can sometimes be impossible to live with

There's more than just that (And even with the con about virginity, I disagree to an extent).


More Pros could include (but are not limited to) our excessive use of formalities, our lack of trust of others, our honourable and honest attitude, our obedience to a higher authority, our ability to make assumption (in some cases) basd on first impressions of others.

Cons could include lack of social conversation (Meh, I converse just fine as long as others speak to me first. However, if others have no interest in me then I find conversation difficult), speech difficulties and mistakes (I feel embarrassed because I stutter too often), lack of ability to realise a dangerous situation before it's too late (true, we're mistrustful and cautious. Somewhat ironically, however, if a giant metal wrecking ball were to fly towards me I wouldn't think "Oh God, move!" as much as I'd think "Is that wrecking ball coming towards me? It is? What is that wrecking ball doing flying towards me? Shouldn't it be at a demolition site?") and mistrust of those that trust you and like you completely."

http://wiki.answers.com/Q/What_are_the_pros_and_cons_of_having_Asperger%27s_syndrome
 
I refuse to pretend to be normal is all I have to say about it. I do not and will not lie, cheat, fake, decieve, pretend or cover up. I just want therapy to help me be myself but better, like communication stuff (which can be cured by gentle reminders to pay attention) and reassurance of how certain things work and emotional support.
 
I refuse to pretend to be normal is all I have to say about it. I do not and will not lie, cheat, fake, decieve, pretend or cover up. I just want therapy to help me be myself but better, like communication stuff (which can be cured by gentle reminders to pay attention) and reassurance of how certain things work and emotional support.

As my Psych says"What is normal?" hehehe i think im normal and everyone else is crazy! hehe:)
 
That's what everyone says until a pedophile comes along, or you abort your child with downs syndrome.
Sorry, but it's the truth.
My social skills teacher says the same thing, but when I try to explain to her about the stigmas towards things like pedophillia and stuff she just gets arrogant and says it's just wrong. Apparently it also makes me one when I defend them.
Yeah.
I enjoy making controversial posts o_O.
EMZ=]
 
"The cons are being denied health insurance, being denied in the military, unable to find a job in the UK. "

Wait wait wait, you are denied health insurance because of AS in the UK?
 
"The cons are being denied health insurance, being denied in the military, unable to find a job in the UK. "

Wait wait wait, you are denied health insurance because of AS in the UK?

No, the UK doesn't run a system like in the US. Everyone can get free health care via NHS... right?
 
Yes, in the UK everyone has free health care. However, getting a diagnosis from the NHS literally takes years.

As for the pros and cons of getting one, it depends on the person, and how old you are. Some people need it to be secure with the fact they're on the spectrum, and if you're still in school a diagnosis will get you support, a statement moreso.
 

New Threads

Top Bottom