If you genuinely say to someone “I want to be friends,” and you are not together, make sure you think it all the way through – would you still feel that way if he started seeing someone tomorrow? I don’t mean to put ideas in your head that that would actually happen, but being friends means just that. It doesn’t mean slowly drawing this out and staying emotionally entangled when each person actually needs to grow.
It may be more useful to consider being friends in the future. His responses to you actually seem really honest, vulnerable, and true. You can absolutely love someone but not want to be with them at the same time.
Calling someone’s actions cruel and vicious suggests that you really need space. He cannot live in guilt forever.
Also, you straight up said “I don’t care that we broke up.” Based on what you have shared here with us, you definitely care that you broke up, so it starts to feel like you are just trying to be strong and stoic for him and to move on with friendship instead of really taking space from each other.
I offer these thoughts in friendliness. I understand that this is a sad and stressful situation for you. But someone saying I love you but I just can’t be with you right now makes perfect sense to me and I have been in that position more than once.
It may be more useful to consider being friends in the future. His responses to you actually seem really honest, vulnerable, and true. You can absolutely love someone but not want to be with them at the same time.
Calling someone’s actions cruel and vicious suggests that you really need space. He cannot live in guilt forever.
Also, you straight up said “I don’t care that we broke up.” Based on what you have shared here with us, you definitely care that you broke up, so it starts to feel like you are just trying to be strong and stoic for him and to move on with friendship instead of really taking space from each other.
I offer these thoughts in friendliness. I understand that this is a sad and stressful situation for you. But someone saying I love you but I just can’t be with you right now makes perfect sense to me and I have been in that position more than once.