There's no logical reason to just randomly call out comments to strangers.
I'm inclined to think most of us Aspies don't appreciate being approached by strangers in general. I realize some people are just being friendly, while some have various agendas. But I always feel a bit "ambushed" when approached by a stranger for much of any reason IRL.
I agree with that.
Even when I know some people are just trying to be friendly, I don't really appreciate it.
Apart from being a kind of interruption while I might be thinking about something completly different and not being in the "speaking mode", it's also that it is so unexpected and I don't know what to answer.
I have to switch from my "thought mode" in my mind to communication. I guess it takes an unusal amount of time and effort for me and when someone forces me to do that without a logical reason, I feel rather annoyed instead of being able to appreciate the friendliness.
I mostly get those random comments while going to school by train, so I keep a book with me there now. It makes it obvious that I am busy and don't want to talk right now when I read.
If they are truly trying to be friendly, they are failing miserably. Making random comments about how I look or what I'm doing, for the sole sake of talking to me or getting my attention, will always have the opposite effect. I don't care what the social norm is; that's not how I work.
Yes, that's true for me as well.
I guess for me it's especially the fact that those comments are never something I actually feel like talking about (or is worth talking about, like people commenting on the weather).
I think it would be far more interesting when people would comment on something I am interested in, but how would they know what I like? That's probably what
Maelstrom is referring to too. They use those general comments to start a conversation and check if there might be shared interests or something like that which could lead to a better conversation (assuming they are really just trying to be friendly and that's their intention).
Actually it is how people make friends....it's called a opener...you say a little something and see if it is welcomed...if it is then maybe a more normal friendly conversation comes then or later.
It is not random, it is testing friendliness.
But people sometimes do that very randomly as it seems, like in situations I wouldn't expect people to want to make friends with me or when I'm quite sure this isn't their intention at all.
I understand that in some situations those openers are supposed to be followed by a further conversation if there's interest on both sides, but I still get random comments by strangers for no real reason.
I can see though that this approach sometimes makes it hard for me to start conversations and make friends myself. For example when I notice something interesting about a person, I don't want to bother them and stay quiet because for me it can be annoying to be talked to randomly. But of course I have no chance to make contact with them at all this way.